Television Interview, ABC Afternoon Briefing

Release details

Release type

Related ministers and contacts


The Hon Richard Marles MP

Deputy Prime Minister

Minister for Defence

Media contact

dpm.media@defence.gov.au

02 6277 7800

Release content

18 November 2026

SUBJECTS: APEC; Australia-China Relationship; Defence Estate Audit; AI; Data Centres; Victorian Election; Cost of Living; Cricket Australia. 

PATRICIA KARVELAS, HOST: For more, I want to bring in Acting Prime Minister and Defence Minister Richard Marles. Welcome to the program. 

RICHARD MARLES, DEPUTY PRIME MINISTER: Good afternoon, Patricia. How are you?

KARVELAS: Especially on the desk. My favourite place for anyone to be.

MARLES: Indeed.

KARVELAS: The Prime Minister has landed in China ahead of the APEC meeting. He's mentioned the things he will raise. What does success look like? Does he need to get a deal to get rid of this 55% tariff on our beef?

MARLES: Well, I think China is our largest trading partner. I mean, they're a critical nation for us. This will be an important meeting at the end of the week in terms of the annual leaders’ meeting between Australia and China, and we'll be raising all the issues in our national interest, but trade is clearly a part of that and you've heard what the Prime Minister has just said there. And more broadly, in terms of the APEC meeting in Shenzhen, that is– I mean, the overwhelming bulk of our trade exists within the APEC region. It is a critical gathering of leaders. It'll be an opportunity to meet bilaterally with a number of them as well, including President Xi. So, you know, I think both are very important moments for the Prime Minister and for the country.

KARVELAS: So, what does success look like, though? Does he need to do a deal on that? I mean, that is–

MARLES: I think putting specifics like that in respect of any meeting is just not how things work in terms of global engagement. You know, all of these meetings take their place in an ongoing relationship and making sure that we build the relationship and take it further. I guess the way to answer that question is, success looks like what we've done over the last four and a half years in terms of greatly increasing the level of trade that we have with China and seeing a lot of that come back online. What matters is that we continue the relationship which enables that to continue.

KARVELAS: On China, you said in a speech a couple of days ago that our biggest risk is not that we risk being invaded, but we’ll be cut off from the world. The Strait of Hormuz has been closed since March. Is there a backup plan if the South China Sea is closed?

MARLES: Well, the point I was making, not necessarily as dramatic as being cut off from the world, but the physical manifestation of our economic connection to the world, you know, is the arteries of our economy. That’s–

KARVELAS: So how worried are you about that scenario playing out?

MARLES: Well, the reason why I described that on Monday night, and I've described it previously, as being our most consequential strategic risk is precisely because it is. You know, our sea lines of communication are fundamentally important given we are an island trading nation with a growing proportion of our national income being derived from trade. And, you know, the conversation we've just had in relation to China demonstrates how important trade is for our nation. When we think about what is our most consequential security risk, it really isn't that the continent would be invaded or the country would be invaded, because there's a whole lot that any adversary could do before ever having set foot on our shores. And you're right in terms of highlighting the Strait of Hormuz. We import north of 90% of our liquid fuels. We've seen a body of water, I think it's 10,000 kilometres from Australia, in a different hemisphere, be substantially closed through most of this year. And we can see what impact that's had on petrol bowsers around the country and for that matter, around the world. It highlights how important freedom of navigation is in relation to those sea lines of communication. And the bulk of the work that the Royal Australian Navy does now is around asserting that rules‑based order, the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, freedom of navigation in areas where our trade routes exist.

KARVELAS: Now, you are not in the Senate, but you know it's been sitting this week. The Coalition, the Greens and crossbenches all teamed up and passed a motion condemning your government and your decision for moving Defence personnel out of the Victoria Barracks in Sydney and calling on you to reverse course. That's quite the alliance. Will you revisit it?

MARLES: We've been really clear about the Defence Estate Audit, about its importance, about the fact that we can't continue to be spending thousands, but not thousands, hundreds of millions of dollars on Defence sites that we either underuse or don't use at all. When we came to government, it was clear that Defence, as one of the largest landowners in the country, was operating a whole lot of sites that it didn't properly use. We commissioned the Defence Estate Audit back in 2023. Jan Mason and Jim Miller, both experts in the field, had a look at all of this, found that there were a whole lot of sites– I mean, it was damning in terms of its assessment around the sites that weren't being properly used. But more than that, it talked about the fact that the hundreds of millions that we are spending now is a burden that defence is having to wear because of the failure to make difficult decisions in the past. And so we are–

KARVELAS: Ok, you made a difficult decision and then you back flipped on it? 

MARLES: Well, the decision we made is to have Defence vacate the 67 sites that in our response to the Defence Estate Audit we said should not be maintained as Defence sites. We are continuing through with that. And that does include Victoria Barracks Sydney. And so– 

KARVELAS: So there'll be no change? I mean, the Coalition's put forward that you should actually not move them out. You're saying they will be moved out. There is no–?

MARLES: Well, I think one of the points they will– we're moving and we're moving not just there, but across the 67 sites. And we said that back in February. There’s no change to that– 

KARVELAS: So you guarantee no further backdowns?

MARLES: We are moving out of those sites. We announced that back February– 

KARVELAS: Will there be no further backdowns?

MARLES: We're moving out of them. I'm making that really clear. And what– 

KARVELAS: You already backed down on those four. There'll be no more?

MARLES: Well, when you say that, we haven't backed down on those four in the sense that we are moving out of those four as well, all we've said–

KARVELAS: Not selling them.

MARLES: Yeah, all we've said in relation to those four is that in terms of their future, we'll keep them in public hands, not in the Department of Defence. And the main thing here is that we are not spending hundreds of millions of dollars. I mean, in the case of Victoria Barracks Sydney, we're talking about $200 million over the next decade to maintain it as a Defence site with all the security that goes along with that.

KARVELAS: So it's going to cost the taxpayer more now that you've backed down?

MARLES: Well–

KARVELAS: If it's $200 million.

MARLES: No. Step back a bit. It's $200 million to maintain it as a Defence site. If you're not maintaining it as a Defence site, that the bill is not the same. And in answer–

KARVELAS: Do we know what the bill will be, though? 

MARLES: It doesn't change, actually, the economics of the decision. So that– the assessment–

KARVELAS: Is it still $200 million then, if it doesn't change it? I mean, like, what does it cost then? Because it's still in public hands.

MARLES: Ok, let's start again, Patricia. We do not need to spend the $200 million to maintain it as a Defence site if it is not a Defence site. 

KARVELAS: But it's in public hands, you're still spending money.

MARLES: Well, it's being managed in a completely different way. And what we've said in relation to that site is that we will maximise its use in terms of community and commercial uses. I think the point to make here is that because there was a very significant heritage overlay in respect of that site, but the other historic sites, the commercial value of them actually wasn't anywhere near what people imagined it would be. And so in terms of the overall finances of this decision, across the 67 sites where it's anticipated that there will be about $3 billion returned to government from the sale, but there will be around $1.2 to $1.8 billion spent on readying them for sale, none of that actually changes by virtue of them being maintained in public hands, but being maximised for community and commercial use. So that's the answer to the question. But it is really important to say that we are saving money by not maintaining this as a Defence site. And this is the real point here, Patricia. Like my priority as the Defence Minister has to be around the defence of the nation. You know, every person who wears our nation's uniform matters– 

KARVELAS: Sure. 

MARLES: –Every hour that they spend in it counts and every dollar that is there to resource them is precious–

KARVELAS: So– 

MARLES: But if I can just finish. What I'm about is trying to make sure that our Army has long‑range fires, that we are able to make it more amphibious, that we're able to invest in northern– 

KARVELAS: Yeah, you're modernising the Defence Force, I get that.

MARLES: –bases. No one is seriously suggesting that Victoria Barracks Sydney in 2026 forms part of the defence of the nation.

KARVELAS: I get that. Senior Defence officials who are in charge of this process were only told about this backflip just a couple of days before you announced it. Why weren't they involved in the process?

MARLES: Well, we have worked with the–

KARVELAS: They confirmed that though to the Senate.

MARLES: We work with the department very closely around, you know, first and foremost from a defence point of view, moving out of the site and as I say, that continues, you know, in full progress. In terms of the ultimate handling of the site, this is going to take time to work through. What we said back in February was that our ambition was to get Defence out of all of the sites in the course of two years. We're on track to do that. Some will get out of there sooner than later. In respect to Victoria Barracks Sydney, we will largely be out of that site by the end of this year. From there the sites are handed over to the Department of Finance and from there the future of these sites is then determined. What we’re–

KARVELAS: So is it normal that the department would only know, you know, only a couple of days before?

MARLES: Right now we're in the process of getting Defence off Victoria Barracks Sydney. That's the work that continues. From there, over the coming years, we will be determining how Victoria Barracks Sydney is activated. You know, there's a lot to work through there. What we've said is that in terms of the activation of that site and three others, to add an added layer of protection to the heritage value of the buildings, we will keep them in public hands.

KARVELAS: I have to ask you a couple of questions on AI, which I think is the biggest disruptor that I've seen in my lifetime. Federal Cabinet has discussed building a sovereign frontier AI model. Katy Gallagher has confirmed that. Is that something that's still being explored?

MARLES: Well, we're working through the whole– everything in respect of AI. 

KARVELAS: Including a sovereign frontier AI model that's Australian? 

MARLES: We're working through how we can make sure that models apply in Australia, by which I mean comprehend our laws, are able to comprehend our culture, I guess and– 

KARVELAS: I get all that, but I'm asking a really specific question about a sovereign independent model. That's not the US, that's not Chinese. Because if you look at the anxiety around AI, people are rightly concerned about these big companies from the US determining the future. Should Australia be making something independent?

MARLES: Well, I think what matters here is that we are engaging with AI and that means engaging with those companies. They are the leaders in the field–

KARVELAS: They're also American and they don't have our Australia first best interests. They don't. They can't possibly. So, is it worth pursuing something sovereign?

MARLES: They are the models that are being used on lots of people's phones around the country right now and there–

KARVELAS: So you don't think there is a case for that?

MARLES: That’s not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that we need to be engaging with those companies. We need to be establishing standards in respect of how AI operates in Australia, irrespective of who is developing it. We need to be developing standards in respect of, you know, data centres, where they're located, how they are powered. They are the critical issues that we need to be working through and we are. But we are doing this from the perspective, you know, I think to agree with your thing at the start, which is that this may well be the most significant technology that any of us see in our lifetime. If we want to shape that, we need to be engaging and that’s the principle that we are pursuing here and engaging with those companies.

KARVELAS: Ok. 

MARLES: And there may well be– 

KARVELAS: In terms of a sovereign model?

MARLES: Well, there may be a place for a sovereign model, but the point really here is that–

KARVELAS: I think lots of Australians would like to use a sovereign model that isn't anchored entirely in the United States, owned by just two men.

MARLES: And that may well be the case. The point is that a whole lot of Australians are using those models that are being generated by American tech now. The reality that we face is, you know, we’re not going to be able to create a world where that's not used in Australia and they are the market leaders, but also the technology leaders and they are a long way ahead in–

KARVELAS: Oh yeah, absolutely. There’s no contesting that.

MARLES: Okay, but if I can just finish. Therefore, you know, from our perspective as a government, the focus here needs to be on how those models operate in Australia, how we can engage with those companies to shape the development of AI, and also how we can pursue this in respect of our own national security.

KARVELAS: Jimmy Barnes, Paul Kelly. They say don't touch copyright. Would you promise not to touch copyright?

MARLES: Well, I think what we want to see is that all of those creatives have agency in relation to–

KARVELAS: They're saying their agency is don't touch it.

MARLES: Again, if I can finish. I think a lot of those creatives need to have more agency and right now they are not. You know, there are plenty of times where their work is being scraped and where they're not getting compensated for it. They should be compensated for it. And again, we are coming to this from the perspective of how do those creators properly get compensated for their work? They should be properly compensated for it. I don't think anyone is suggesting that what exists right now, the status quo, serves them. And if we want to improve their situation in respect of this technology, if we want to improve their remuneration in respect of this technology, then we need to engage.

KARVELAS: You haven't convinced them yet though, have you?

MARLES: Well, I mean, what we will do is keep pursuing this. I mean, this is a really– it is, as you say, a transformational technology. It is a challenging area of policy. What we want to see is a situation where Australians are protected, where creatives are properly remunerated, where news organisations are properly remunerated. We can do all of that. Where data centres, which represent an opportunity, are built in a way that–

KARVELAS: I have to ask on data centres. 

MARLES: Where date centres–

KARVELAS: I need to interrupt, because I've got so many good questions.

MARLES: Great. Where data centres are built in the appropriate place and where they are powered in the appropriate way and where our sovereignty is protected.

KARVELAS: Data centres. You said you don't want them in the suburbs. They're already in the suburbs.

MARLES: Well, I'm saying, you know, in terms of how standards are pursued in respect of data centres going forward, there are places that are appropriate and there are places that are not–

KARVELAS: So right now, some of them that have been built in the suburbs. Wrong decision?

MARLES: Well, I mean, ultimately I think planning schemes are a matter for the states, of course. You know, I think there are places that are obviously not appropriate for data centres– 

KARVELAS: Mistakes have been made, do you think, though?

MARLES: I think there are places that are obviously not appropriate for data centres. 

KARVELAS: Footscray?

MARLES: Well, I mean, I think there are places that are obviously not appropriate for data centres, in answer to that specific question. They do need to be built in the right place, not the wrong place. And there needs to be the right approach in respect of how they are powered and, I don't know if this is the right word, but how they are watered. 

KARVELAS: Watered. I like it. 

MARLES: So, water sometimes is a function of power, but they are consumers of water and power and so how that works in respect to them is really important as well. We've got to get all of that right. If we do, there's a huge economic opportunity here. Clearly, if we don't, you know, this can be something which can be disruptive. And we've seen that play out in the United States, and I think that is one of the lessons of the midterms. But that's why we're very focused on making sure that we get the standards in relation to all of this right. They are the critical issues in respect of AI. We need to engage. We can't turn our back on this. And it is a complex policy area.

KARVELAS: Just a couple of questions, obviously there's a Victorian election. Labor's tanking, right?

MARLES: Well, I mean, let's see what happens on– 

KARVELAS: It's not looking good.

MARLES: Well, let's see what happens on Saturday week– 

KARVELAS: I know, but you live in reality. You're a smart man.

MARLES: I think Ben Carroll is doing a great job in terms of running–

KARVELAS: Did you see how badly his results were in the debate? 

MARLES: I think Ben Carroll is doing a great job in presenting a very practical position in respect of what the next four years would look like under Labor, in terms of investing in health and education and what the risks are– 

KARVELAS: Come on. It's damaging the Labor brand, isn't it? This Labor government?

MARLES: Again, I think Ben Carroll's doing a great job as the Premier and he's doing a great job in the way in which he's pursuing this campaign and let's see what decision people make on election day.

KARVELAS: Pauline Hanson hasn't been really on the campaign trail much. I wrote about this a couple of days ago. But I've had a little look and she's actually been in your electorate.

MARLES: She has. 

KARVELAS: In Corio. And then I looked and One Nation, I think, got 15% of the vote there already before their rise. Are you worried about your own electorate?

MARLES: Right now, we are focused on– doing my job as the Deputy Prime Minister, the Minister for Defence, on– 

KARVELAS: But you must be a little bit, given 15% even before their ascendancy?

MARLES: Well, what I would say in relation to my own seat is I don't take anyone's view of me or their vote in an election for granted. I never have and I won't at the next election. And so I will continue to make my case as the Member for Corio to the electorate and the constituents of Corio and none of that changes.

KARVELAS: But you can see this coming, as someone who’s been in politics a long time?

MARLES: I mean, I'll continue to do what I do, representing the constituents of Corio to the best of my ability, fulfilling my roles as the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Defence. And definitely not taking anyone's vote for granted and I never have.

KARVELAS: Ok. It is tricky though, isn't it? People are very angry about cost of living.

MARLES: Well we understand that people are doing it tough. I mean, we do. And we've seen, you know, the interest rate rises and that definitely has not made anything easier– 

KARVELAS: No, people are really angry. 

MARLES: And we are very mindful of that. In terms of managing government spending, which is, you know, part of the whole equation that we're responsible for, we believe we have been doing that in a prudent way relative to what we inherited in terms of the federal budget–

KARVELAS: Should we expect an austerity budget?

MARLES: Again, if I can just finish, relative to what we inherited as a federal government. We are spending much less than what was projected by the former Coalition and we are spending less than what is being promised by the current Coalition. So spending is very much front and centre. Where we do spend, we are focused on cost of living measures–

KARVELAS: But more cuts to come? 

MARLES: –But we are really mindful that Australians are doing it tough and we are doing everything within our power to guide us through this period. I think, you know, when you look further afield, further down the track, we can get through this. But right now it is a very difficult time and we acknowledge that.

KARVELAS: Very sneaky last one. You know I love taking up time. If I can colonise your time. Cricket Australia. I mean, I think you like cricket?

MARLES: I do.

KARVELAS: Ok. Shouldn't the findings of this be made public?

MARLES: Well, this is a matter for Cricket Australia, so I'm not about to weigh into this. Obviously, there's been a process that occurred back at the time of this issue. It's a matter for Cricket Australia to work through.

KARVELAS: But they're our national cricket team. 

MARLES: They are. 

KARVELAS: And there are contested versions of what happened. Shouldn't it be made publicly available for all Australians to see?

MARLES: Well, again, these are a set of decisions that are being made by Cricket Australia. I've got confidence in the way in which Cricket Australia is handling this. You know, I understand people's interest in this. There was a process that occurred previously. There was consequence associated with that process. You know, to be honest, I come to this principally as a cricket fan and from that perspective, you know, I'm really looking forward to the summer ahead against New Zealand, our tour of India and the Ashes in the middle of next year.

KARVELAS: This is all clouding it, though?

MARLES: Well, you know, for me, I am very much focused on what's going to be happening over the summer. I have confidence in Cricket Australia being able to manage this and I'll let them do it.

KARVELAS: All right, fair enough. You've been generous with your time. Thank you.

MARLES: Thanks, Patricia.

ENDS

Other related releases